Please wait while we process your request

Brexit and Scottish Independence: Assessing the Impact on Devolution

Words: 587 | Pages: 3

This essay sample was donated by a student to help the academic community. Papers provided by Pro-Papers writers usually outdo students' samples.
Download

Scottish independence is not new in British politics; it has been part of public discourse for decades but gained significant momentum since devolution started in late 1990s. The Scottish National Party (SNP), advocating for Scotland's self-governance, won an outright majority in the Scottish Parliament election in May 2011, which led to a historic independence referendum on September 18th, 2014. In spite of their campaign efforts though, Scots chose to stay as part of UK with a margin favoring unionists by roughly ten points (55% against versus 45% for). However post-Brexit realities have reignited these debates around independence given that many Scots feel they are being dragged out against their will from EU through Brexit.


Examination of the Devolution Process in Scotland


Brexit has fundamentally challenged this status quo by raising questions about where ultimate sovereignty lies. It is notable that while England and Wales voted for Brexit in 2016 referendum (53.4% & 52.5% respectively), Scotland overwhelmingly voted against it (62%). This divergence gave rise to claims that devolution is flawed as it doesn't fully protect Scottish interests from decisions taken at UK level - such as Brexit - where English votes often dominate due to sheer population size difference. It also reignited calls for further independence; if key decisions like EU membership affecting Scotland are taken without its consensus then perhaps complete self-governance would be more suitable than partial one offered by devolution.


Brexit's Influence on the Devolution Debate


The influence is not just rhetorical but practical too. Post-Brexit power repatriation process from Brussels has been complex and contentious because many areas previously under EU jurisdiction fall within competencies devolved to Scotland (e.G., agriculture, fisheries). Instead of these powers going directly to Edinburgh post-Brexit, they were initially returned to Westminster for establishing common frameworks across UK before any further devolution. This approach was perceived as 'power grab' by SNP as it encroached upon their domain; thereby exacerbating existing tensions around sovereignty issues.


Impact of Brexit on Scottish Independence Aspirations


The SNP argues that if Scotland were independent, it could decide its own foreign policy, including possibly rejoining EU or forging closer ties with other European bodies like Nordic Council. Their case is also bolstered by the argument that since circumstances have significantly changed after 2016 (i.E., Brexit), prior mandate from 2014 doesn't hold; hence requiring fresh public consultation on question of self-governance. Thus, what started as an issue around devolution and power repatriation post-Brexit has escalated into a full-blown sovereignty debate in Scotland.


Consequences of Scottish Independence for UK Devolution


Scottish secession could prompt other regions to reconsider their own position within the UK union. For instance, calls for Welsh independence might intensify or Northern Ireland may seek reunification with the Republic of Ireland. This could destabilize not just existing devolved structures but also threaten constitutional integrity of UK itself by fuelling separatist sentiments elsewhere. Henceforth, while an independent Scotland could serve as an inspiration for some regional nationalist movements; it equally holds potential for creating unprecedented challenges around redefining governance norms post-devolution.


Future Implications for Devolution in the Light of Brexit and Potential Scottish Independence


If Scotland were to gain independence following another referendum, this could potentially lead to a complete overhaul of devolved powers in what remains of the UK. With Northern Ireland also voting against Brexit, there may even be calls for increased self-governance there too. All these point towards a future where devolution processes might have to become more nuanced and flexible - accounting not just for regional identities but also their distinct political preferences - rather than having one-size-fits-all approach like currently.

Work Cited

1

But I must explain to you how all this mistaken idea of denouncing pleasure and praising pain was born and I will give you a complete account of the system, and expound the actual teachings of the great explorer of the truth, the master-builder of human happiness.

2

"At vero eos et accusamus et iusto odio dignissimos ducimus qui blanditiis praesentium voluptatum deleniti atque corrupti quos dolores et quas molestias excepturi sint occaecati cupiditate non provident."

3

"On the other hand, we denounce with righteous indignation and dislike men who are so beguiled and demoralized by the charms of pleasure of the moment, so blinded by desire, that they cannot foresee the pain and trouble that are bound to ensue."

Try it now!

USD
10

Calculate your price

Number of pages:

Order Now

Related samples

Examine how baptism evolved in the Early Church, from its role in initiation and salvation to debates over its administration and… .

Baptism Essay Examples

0 / 5

62

Embark on a philosophical journey exploring Hinduism's environmental ethics. Delve into the profound connection between Hindu philosophy and nature,… .

Hinduism Essay Examples

0 / 5

102

Explore the impact of education and environment on the development of free will. Uncover how nurture shapes the nature of personal agency, examining… .

Free Will Essay Examples

0 / 5

132

We can take care of your essay

24/7 Support

We really care about our clients and strive to provide the best customer experience for everyone.

Fair and Flexible Cost

Fair and flexible cost affordable for every student.

Plagiarism-free Papers

Plagiarized texts are unacceptable in the academic community, and our team knows it perfectly well. For this reason, we have strict plagiarism detection tools which we use for each of our orders.

Compliance with Any Deadline

The minimal timeframe needed to complete your paper is 6 hours. So if you need your paper by tomorrow, this is the job for our experts!